7 Ways to Handle Big Holiday Meals with Picky Eaters (2024)

Modified: November 6, 2023

This post is brought to you by FunBites. Affiliate links used below. See our full disclosure.

The holiday season is nearly here, and with that usually comes big holiday meals often with people outside of your immediate family. These meals typically include long standing family traditions and more, how should I say, adult food, which can mean a major upset for a picky eater or problem feeder. Parents also feel the stress as well-meaning relatives offer their unsolicited advice and their children subsequently eat nothing! Avoiding this scenario all together is tempting, but I can assure you it is not necessary. You and your child can survive that holiday meal, in fact, it can even be enjoyable for everyone involved.

Thanks to our fantastic sponsor, Funbites, I am able to bring you this Successful Holiday MealGuide for Picky Eaters. FunBites is a family owned business that developed a shape cutter for foods to help picky eaters, like their daughter, eat new foods. My family has been using their cutters for years, and we love them! Picky eater or not, kids can have a lot of fun with FunBites as they allow kids to make their own food creations. Now is a perfect time to grab some for stocking stuffers!

7 Ways to Handle Big Holiday Meals with Picky Eaters (2)

SUCCESSFUL HOLIDAY MEAL GUIDE FOR PICKY EATERS

1.Call Ahead – In all my years working with families, the biggest concern for parents was dealing with family members questioning why they weren’t making their kid eat x, y, or z. In order to head this off, I suggest calling a few key family members and friends ahead of time, word will spread. Try to keep the conversation relaxed, and mention that you are aware of “Johnny’s” limited choices and although you’re addressing it, you won’t be at Thanksgiving dinner. This advance call will likely give them a chance to get all that sage advice off their chest, so they can focus on other things at the meal.

2. Make enough for everyoneTake a preferred food of your child’s to dinner on a serving platter to imply that anyone can eat it, even if it is unlikely that they actually will. While it may seem strange to have peanut butter and jelly at Christmasdinner, it allows you to have something your child will eat without sending him the message that he has his own special food.

I recommend having your kid get involved with helping prepare this meal. Funbites are safe for kids to use and will motivate other’s to share in what your child has made (especially other kiddos).

We made these garlic bread “bites” and dipping sauce with the FunBites heart shaped cutter.

3. Bulk up on other meals that day– If you aren’t going to take anything special to the party for your child to eat, then bulk up on the meals earlier in the day. Try to serve something that they really love for breakfast and lunch, so you can feel better about them skimping on dinner. You can also plan on having a snack (maybe larger than normal) before bed.

4. Offer to bring dessert – Many (not all) picky eaters will often eat a wider variety of desserts. Although it isn’t ideal, in this special circ*mstance, your child having a bowl of ice-cream and/or some cookies will likely give you some peace of mind if they have barely eaten any dinner. Of course, you may need to bring these things because sometimes the dessert menu may be minced meat pie or fruit cake, and even if the most adventurous eaters will struggle to try those desserts.

5. Avoid Surprises– Prep your little one by talking briefly about what will be on the menu ahead of time (you can obtain this information when you call Auntie in advance!). At a minimum, you will want to let your kiddo know that they will be sitting down for dinner and there will be a lot of foods to choose from. Reassure them that you are there to help, but it is there choice if they eat a particular food or not.

Depending on your child’s age, you may also want to spend some time talking to them about how to politely refuse (or try) food. At home you may allow your child to spit food out, show them an appropriate way to do that if it is something you are working on. More extreme picky eaters may even benefit from a role playing exercise.

6. Take a little – I love when kids can serve themselves at afamily stylemeal, and it is a strategy I definitely recommend in general. If this is something you are already doing at home, this is a fantastic opportunity to expose your child to something different. Also, it helps set the precedent that you aren’t going to cater to them. However, if you’ve never served family style and your child doesn’t understand that they should take some food this could be overwhelming. In this case, choose one or two foods and only place a little on the plate, helping your child as necessary.

7. Set the bar low, very low– Once you’ve put the above strategies in place, know you’ve done everything you can do and letgo of any expectations you have for your child to eat. Try to enjoy yourself and don’t allow your child to be your focus during the meal. The added benefit will be that your child will feel no pressure to eat and then conversely may actually try something!

What have you tried at holiday meals in the past? What worked? What didn’t?

Don’t forget to check out all the differentFUNBITESshapes!

More on Picky Eaters

Getting Your Picky Eater to Explore New Foods

Sensory Processing and Picky Eating

Turning My Picky Eater Around

7 Ways to Handle Big Holiday Meals with Picky Eaters (6)

Alisha Grogan is a licensed occupational therapist and founder of Your Kid’s Table. She has over 14 years experience with expertise in sensory processing and feeding development in babies, toddlers, and children. Alisha also has 3 boys of her own at home. Learn more about her here.

7 Ways to Handle Big Holiday Meals with Picky Eaters (2024)

FAQs

How do you deal with an extreme picky eater? ›

The goal for feeding a picky eater should be to try new foods and to keep food from starting a battle.
  1. Share Responsibility. ...
  2. Offer a Variety of Age-Appropriate Foods. ...
  3. Limit High Calorie Drinks. ...
  4. Set a Meal Schedule. ...
  5. Make Meals Pleasant. ...
  6. Respect Eating Quirks. ...
  7. Avoid Being a Short Order Cook. ...
  8. Don't Always Offer Dessert.

What is food neophobia? ›

Food neophobia is the tendency to reject or be reluctant to try new and unfamiliar foods.

What is the picky eater rule? ›

You may have heard it called the “one bite rule” or the “one polite bite” or the “no thank you bite” or the “try it bite”. Regardless of what you call it, it's the concept that a child (usually a picky eater) should take at least one bite of every food on their plate.

What not to say to a picky eater? ›

To help your child develop a healthy relationship with food, avoid these four toxic phrases:
  • “You can have dessert after you eat your broccoli.” ...
  • “If you're quiet, I'll give you a cookie.” ...
  • “You have to take one more bite before you can say 'no. ...
  • “It would make me happy if you took three more bites.”
Apr 22, 2023

What age does picky eating end? ›

Do remember that picky eating is often “developmentally normal.” Children across the globe go through a picky eating phase from about age 2 to about age 4.

What is the one bite rule for picky eaters? ›

'One bite' tactic

Pushing children to eat all the food on their plate or enforcing the "one bite" rule isn't recommended. Instead, parents should let children learn to eat in their own way. Keeping mealtime tactics consistent is also important.

Are picky eaters born or made? ›

It appears it be both. Some estimates claim 78% of picky eating is due to heritable or developmental characteristics – how the taste buds and smell centers of the brain perceive flavour and how a child's taste is designed to mature with time.

What foods do picky eaters not like? ›

While every kid is different, commonly refused foods include:
  • Odorous vegetables. ...
  • Seafood & Sushi. ...
  • Condiments. ...
  • Spicy Foods. ...
  • Sandwiches.
Nov 4, 2022

Should I force my picky eater to eat? ›

Resist the urge to force a child to eat or engage in mealtime battles. But don't cater to picky preferences, either. Continue offering at least one food your child likes at each meal along with a healthy balance of other foods whether your child eats them or not.

How do you discipline a picky eater? ›

10 Tips to Deal with Picky Eaters
  1. A taste is just a taste! ...
  2. Repeat disliked foods. ...
  3. Involve your child in food preparation. ...
  4. Do not force-feed your child. ...
  5. Set a good example. ...
  6. Remove distractions at mealtime. ...
  7. Do not use food as a method of discipline or reward. ...
  8. Limit drinks before and during a meal.

Is extreme picky eating autism? ›

A recent review of scientific studies found that children with autism are five times more likely to have mealtime challenges such as extremely narrow food selections, ritualistic eating behaviors (e.g. no foods can touch) and meal-related tantrums.

What is it called when you are an extremely picky eater? ›

Avoidant restrictive food intake disorder (ARFID) is an eating disorder. If you have it, you'll limit the amount and type of food you eat. Doctors sometimes call ARFID selective eating disorder.

Can picky eaters be cured? ›

Picky eaters can often make lots of progress in about 8 to 10 treatment sessions. It is very common for kids to be slightly picky about what they eat. Finding a child who enjoys green vegetables is certainly harder than finding one who doesn't. But some kids are more than picky eaters.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Dr. Pierre Goyette

Last Updated:

Views: 5919

Rating: 5 / 5 (50 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Dr. Pierre Goyette

Birthday: 1998-01-29

Address: Apt. 611 3357 Yong Plain, West Audra, IL 70053

Phone: +5819954278378

Job: Construction Director

Hobby: Embroidery, Creative writing, Shopping, Driving, Stand-up comedy, Coffee roasting, Scrapbooking

Introduction: My name is Dr. Pierre Goyette, I am a enchanting, powerful, jolly, rich, graceful, colorful, zany person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.